Limbaugh said (something to the effect):
"There's no greater prison that a man can put himself in than the desire to be liked."
God works in mysterious ways, no? If there was anything that I needed hear more than that, I wouldn't know.
Over the last few days I know I have lost more than a dozen readers. I've been called a Pharisaical Jew (which I thought was rather anti-Semitic), a Protestant, a "spleen-venting bag of vile" (which was a rather good turn of phrase), a presumptuous fool, a "slander mongering jerk", among other things. I was just told this morning, that I, along with the folks over at Rorate Cæli, have "a disgraceful attitude", and I've gotten the litany from at least a half-dozen people, saying that, not only will they no longer follow this weblog, but they will let everyone know how horrible and terrible of a person I am.
All this for simply pointing out the truth. Someone else left a comment, all in caps, asking how I could be so slanderous as to compare Pope Francis to Father John Corapi. Obviously, that hysterical person missed the point. I wasn't comparing Pope Francis to Father John Corapi, I was comparing him to Father Corapi! I was comparing the people who feel compelled to defend Pope Francis' past policies in regard to traditionalists and the Traditional Latin Mass with those who defended Father Corapi's innocence in the face of overwhelming evidence of misbehavior.
There is an almost "cultish" (and I'm using the word "cult" here in the pejorative sense) in matters of religious personality in the post-Vatican II Church, even on the part of many people who assist at and love the Traditional Latin Mass. The faith goes beyond human reason and understanding, but it never contradicts it. Pointing out the truth is never contrary to the faith, but rather serves it, especially in regards to the august offices of the Church that have been under attack by the Neo-Modernists over the last couple of decades. My criticisms, and I know for a fact, the criticisms coming from New Catholic, and the traditionalists who post in the combox here, are born, not out of hatred or a disgraceful attitude, but a very deep love and adoration for the Office of the Pope and the Throne of St. Peter.
No doubt there are many people who assist at the Traditional Latin Mass who think that I and others must "play nice" and be politically correct in the face of a new Pontificate headed by a man who has been downright uncharitable to traditionalists, and who has demonstrated a certain liturgical disdain for the office immediately following his election. Such harsh criticism might give the Traditional Latin Mass a bad name. That's an opinion, and I've considered it long and hard. However, if we go down that dangerous course, a course of appeasement that allows the vandals to continue to deface the institutions of the Church Militant, we will find ourselves exactly where we were forty years ago, if not worse off. If traditionalists aren't going to question and challenge these things, who will?
In regards to promoting the Traditional Latin Mass one important thing has to be kept in mind in light of our current crisis of faith. There is no better remedy to our present crisis, which is a crisis of faith, than the Traditional Latin Mass, and there is no doubt that folks are better off assisting at the Traditional Latin Mass than the novus ordo. However, the Traditional Latin Mass will come to end. It is not the ultimate teleological principle. At the end of time, when Our Blessed Lord comes in glory, the Mass on earth will cease to be offered. The end cause is not the Traditional Latin Mass. The end cause is Jesus Christ, and He is the ultimate object of both our wills (The Good) and our intellects (The True).
Thus, the purpose of this weblog, to promote the Traditional Latin Mass and traditional Catholicism, is not served by telling convenient lies and obscuring the facts so I can be liked. It is not served by "playing nice" and being politically correct when that means obscuring the truth. If I promote the Traditional Latin Mass and traditional Catholicism by obscuring the truth, even inconvenient truths, then I'm nothing more than a hypocrite and a liar.
An SSPX priest once called me to task for something I wrote here with these words, which had a profound affect on my outlook:
We [SSPX priests and bishops] ask for the freedom to be fully Catholic, both doctrinal and liturgical, in the sense that it was always understood and practiced for centuries before the Council [Vatican II], but what is that freedom worth if we do not, equally, have the freedom to reject what is contrary to it? Is it right for us to say that this over here is true and good, and at the same time remain silent in regards to all those things over there that are opposed to what we know is both true and good? You ask us to live a contradiction.
That's true. In regards to the events of this week, how can I promote on the one hand what I know to be true and good and then on the other hand remain silent to what opposes it? Those who judge me and other traditionalists are asking, no, rather, they are demanding us, to live a contradiction. So to those of you who feel compelled to waste your time spleen venting (I really do like that phrase) in the combox here, I'm fully aware that I will stand before the Judgement Seat of Christ, and my purpose here, and in life, certainly does not include the necessity of being liked by you.
Lastly, I should note that I've had far more positive feedback than negative from the regular readers here at Ars Orandi. I certainly do appreciate the support, and also the understanding for some initial remarks on my part that were, I admit, uncharitable. Please keep me, and other traditionalists who stick their necks out in the new media, in your prayers.
This evening I will offer five extra decades of the Rosary for all those who visit this weblog.
Dear David,
ReplyDeleteIn my earlier comment, which I guess you chose to not post, I offered that I will stop visiting your blog. I will very cautiously continue to visit.
Honestly, it's very difficult for me to look at your blog and RC right now, because they are causing me so much internal distress.
Francis is the Pope. Whether that is our choice, or even the choice of the Holy Ghost will not change that reality. God has allowed it. The Church belongs to the Lord.
Let us pray more fervently, make more sacrifices and penances, and pray that the Holy Father will not take away what we do have.
There is much this pontiff can do to correct much in the church, without affecting the beauty of the Tradition of the Church.
We must keep our trust in God.
And pray. pray. pray.
God Bless you,
Dee Dee
I for one am a proud reader of your blog, and hope you'll keep up the good work.
ReplyDeleteAllow me to post this with my name and avatar so that those that slander you do not even think of wasting time by me.
With sincere esteem.
Mundabor
Well I, for one, desperately want to be liked, and since all the cool kids are trashing you, I'll join in and call you an obtuse piece of flotsam... But other than that, I'd like to just mention my support and agreement for what you have said about the situation. I appreciate your efforts and insights, which have helped me personally, as well as to help explain the current affairs to friends, from a traditional standpoint.
ReplyDeleteBy the way, do you know of any articles which have good facts on what he has done in Argentina? I have heard the Church there to be in shambles, but other than few vocations and reports of repression of traditional Masses/priests, I don't know much. It would be nice to have solid numbers, names, stories, dates, etc for what happened under his watch - so i have more to say when i tell people "vocations are down, and traditional priests are harassed."
Thanks
This isn't comprehensive but contains some valuable information IMHO.
Deletehttp://www.renewamerica.com/columns/marielena/130316
FRANCIS (Jorge Mario Bergoglio) an Argentinian Jesuit from "the end of the world"-- may end up taking you there...
By Marielena Montesino de Stuart - March 16, 2013
Thank you, Mr. Werling. God bless you, your family, and your humble apostolate here.
ReplyDeleteSincerely,
A thankful and regular reader
I too want to encourage you to continue on the course you have set. To distinguish among the many (at times) apparent nuances and paradoxes in the truth(it is after all a fallen world) takes an enormous intellectual effort. It also takes a kind of faith that I believe even many who claim Christ simply don't have. That is why you get the vitriol. They are trying to "whistle past the grave yard" because in reality they are scared to death.
ReplyDeletejlh
David, I am a devoted reader and will continue to be - yours is one of the few sites that I read every day if I can.
ReplyDeleteJerry
Don M says:
ReplyDeleteDavid: I will continue to read your blog. I am waiting, Praying, hoping, etc. The Pope`s chair is not even warm yet.I must pray and wait, before judging events that have not come to pass.
I am Extremely concerned, and will not pretend otherwise.
Many I know are storming Heaven with their prayers. I find it a terrible sign, that so many devout Catholics, are so worried about the Election of a new Pope. What should be the occasion of great joy, has instead become sleepless nights, and worries mutiplied.
Jesus Mercy
Mr. Werling,
ReplyDeleteYour blog is an important resource in my spiritual development, I've highly recommended it to everyone (religious included) at my SSPX chapel.
Could you please consider posting the Collect of the Day the night before so I have food for contemplation for daily Mass?
To you, New Catholic and Mundabor: "Remember my word that I said to you: The servant is not greater than his master. If they have persecuted me, they will also persecute you: if they have kept my word, they will keep yours also."
You are now in my daily Rosary intentions.
God's continued blessings for you and your family.
MarkA
I'll take your suggestion about the Collect of the Day posts into consideration.
DeleteThank you for your consideration, Mr. Werling. Thy blog (decisions) be done, not mine. Regardless, I will come here daily for spiritual refreshment.
DeleteMr. Werling,
ReplyDeleteYour blog is an important resource in my spiritual development, I've highly recommended it to everyone (religious included) at my SSPX chapel.
Could you please consider posting the Collect of the Day the night before so I have food for contemplation for daily Mass?
To you, New Catholic and Mundabor: "Remember my word that I said to you: The servant is not greater than his master. If they have persecuted me, they will also persecute you: if they have kept my word, they will keep yours also."
You are now in my daily Rosary intentions.
God's continued blessings for you and your family.
MarkA
Mr. Werling,
ReplyDeleteYour blog is an important resource in my spiritual development, I've highly recommended it to everyone (religious included) at my SSPX chapel.
Could you please consider posting the Collect of the Day the night before so I have food for contemplation for daily Mass?
To you, New Catholic and Mundabor: "Remember my word that I said to you: The servant is not greater than his master. If they have persecuted me, they will also persecute you: if they have kept my word, they will keep yours also."
You are now in my daily Rosary intentions.
God's continued blessings for you and your family.
MarkA
Well said. You are appreciated and admired. The Truth will be evident in the near future but don't expect apologies, for they will not come. What will come is continued harassment and genuine hatred.
ReplyDeleteThank-you for speaking the Truth in charity. It is a great consolation and guide in these dark days to hear your level-headed, realistic, and genuinely hopeful voice. Keep up the good work, and I will add you to my rosary intentions.
ReplyDeleteI am a traditionalist Muslim and though you are against my very existence I'm sure like nearly the entire world if not the entire world, I keep dropping in on this blog because I find our struggles to be very similar (and I am just very well-read on religion). I've been called every name in the book from everyone and have found that almost none of my coreligionists of all persuasions (in name only, that is) understand what I'm talking about, and as a result I have no friends and can't worship in congregation etc. I've been told that the only ones who do share my beliefs and opinions and things are holed up in the middle of nowhere and interact with no one like the Desert Fathers of old so as to not be corrupted by modernism and the influence of others. Sometimes it seems like that is the only hope and that the only one you have is God, and it is He whose opinion is the only one to worry about.
ReplyDeleteI am absolutely NOT against your "very existence". Such an attitude would exemplify for the Christian a sinful hatred. You can be sure, Kelly, that that kind of hatred is not kept or honored by traditional Catholics. Rather, we ardently desire your happiness, especially that ultimate happiness that comes from life with God in heaven. I will most certainly pray that you will embrace the love and truth of our Blessed Lord, Jesus Christ, and I will ask Mary His Mother, and yours, to pray for your conversion. God bless! and thank you for visiting this weblog.
DeleteI think there are powerful psychological forces at work in the complete inability of many ostensibly or otherwise faithful Catholics to countenance any criticism of the new pope. You are far from the only one to experience these diatribes, these violent reactions against the pointing out of the past record of the now reigning pontiff. I think many of these folks are terrified you're right, and don't want to believe it could be so, so they shoot the messenger. I think you are also right that the Church has devolved for far too many, even many rather pious, traditional souls, into a cult of personality with worship of certain sacrosanct figures, like the holder of the Chair of Peter. There is ultramontanism run amok in the Church today, and I encounter it all the time on my blog and in my personal life. One for instance of that was the insistence on the part of even some otherwise good, traditional priests that the election of the pope is always instigated by the Holy Ghost, that, essentially, the cardinal-electors lose their free will during a conclave and are compelled by the Holy Ghost to arrive at His predetermined selection. This is problematic on so many levels, and very troubling. It denies free will, it denies the fact that the Holy Ghost would then, in the past, have directed the election of men profoundly deleterious to the Church, it reveals a fawning obeisance beyond reason.....it reveals that the rot of modernism, ultramontanism and a certain hyper-clericalism are rampant even among those who should know better.
ReplyDeleteI am extremely concerned at this point. I think anything is possible with this pontificate.
Excellent points. I, too, am concerned with the points you mentioned.
DeleteI am further concerned about these acts of obeisance that the recent Popes have felt compelled to make in the direction of the rabbis as soon as they ascend Peter's chair. Very, very few people are even concerned about this, let alone bothering to write about it. The religious (and political) ramifications of this have the ability to cause enormous harm. I have blogged about it today on my own blog, only because no one else has taken much notice of it. (http://theeye-witness.blogspot.com/ in case anyone is interested).
It is a delicate matter to be sure. But the way the recent Popes have handled it is a far cry from the sensible Catholic position of centuries past.